Latest permanent hike seen as reducing disparities between urban, rural economies
The federal government has updated food assistance benefits to reflect increases in costs for nutritious meals, and new research suggests that the economic advantages of enhanced benefits could be particularly robust in rural areas.
Throughout the pandemic, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits have aided thousands of Granite Staters who have experienced economic hardships or had trouble affording food. Federal analysis estimates that SNAP benefits can spur economic activity, and newly released research indicates that, when the economy is weak, SNAP provides a larger local economic boost in rural areas. Additional recent federal data indicate that temporary pandemic-related increases to SNAP benefits and other program changes may have mitigated expected increases in food insecurity during 2020.
This information and the continued challenges facing individuals and families suggest that permanent increases to SNAP benefits first implemented in October 2021 have begun to provide greater support to individuals and the overall economy throughout the continued recovery from the Covid-19 crisis.
Increases to benefits
During June 2021, the U.S. Department of Agriculture reevaluated the Thrifty Food Plan (TFP), which estimates expenses, nutrition and other factors to calculate maximum SNAP benefits. This recent evaluation of the TFP, which reflects updates to the costs of nutritious meals throughout the nation, resulted in increases to SNAP benefits to respond more closely to the cost of food.
The last time the TFP was comprehensively reevaluated was 15 years ago. This is the first time SNAP benefits have been increased beyond regular inflation adjustments during the program’s history.
The increased SNAP benefits are 21 percent higher on average than benefits would have been without the policy change. This increase is also greater than the temporary 15 percent increase to benefits put in place by federal pandemic-related aid packages, which ended in Oct. 2021. In New Hampshire and the other 47 contiguous states, most SNAP households will receive an additional $12 to $16 per person per month.
For the current federal fiscal year, ending Sept. 30, 2022, USDA estimates an additional $28 million will support individuals, families and NH’s economy as a result of these benefits increases.
Despite these permanent SNAP benefits boosts, or the temporary pandemic-related boosts, research suggests the maximum SNAP benefits still may not cover the average cost of a modestly priced meal in New Hampshire. The new increases in SNAP benefits for most households will reduce the gap between benefit amounts and the costs of meals for all households, including those with the greatest levels of need.
Positive economic impacts
SNAP benefits also provide necessary economic stimulus during times when the economy is weak.
A 2019 USDA analysis estimated that every dollar invested in new SNAP benefits, which are funded by the federal government, would generate approximately $1.50 in economic activity when the economy is weak. This research reflects similar analysis by Moody’s Analytics, which found a greater multiplier effect for SNAP benefits during early 2009, estimating $1.74 of economic activity generated during that time period for every federal dollar invested towards new benefits.
A new USDA analysis estimates that rural economies may experience even greater economic boosts from SNAP benefits compared to urban areas. It also indicates that benefits allowed for household budgets to be stretched further, enabling spending on other household necessities. Due to SNAP benefits, both economic output and employment were estimated to increase at proportionately larger levels in rural areas than in urban areas from 2009 to 2014, during the recovery from the Great Recession. New Hampshire is a relatively rural state and may be more positively impacted by additional SNAP benefits overall compared to more urbanized areas.
Key research into the conditions of the last recovery suggests the increased SNAP benefits may help reduce the disparities between urban and rural economies.
Michael Polizzotti is a policy analyst at the NH Fiscal Policy Institute, which is sharing the article with partners in the Granite State News Collaborative.
